Autonomous AUTONOMOUS
Canadian Expertise. Pakistani Efficiency. World-class Quality.

Shopify CRO Audit

Mama's Marketplace · mamasmarketplace.pk
February 6, 2026

65
Overall CRO Score
7/10
Homepage
7/10
Product Page
5/10
Cart & Checkout

Executive Summary

Mama's Marketplace has built a strong foundation as Pakistan's sustainable baby marketplace. The brand story resonates, WhatsApp integration is present, and COD support is in place. However, critical trust signals are missing across the entire funnel, and the checkout flow lacks modern conveniences expected by today's shoppers.

Top 3 Priority Issues

Critical

No Trust Badges

Zero payment/security badges anywhere on site. Critical for first-time buyers in Pakistan.

High

No Shipping Info

Delivery times and free shipping thresholds aren't visible until checkout. Causes abandonment.

High

No Urgency/Scarcity

No stock indicators, no limited-time offers. Secondhand marketplace should leverage scarcity.

CVR Projections

Estimated Current
1.2%
Pakistan avg: 1.0-1.5%
After Quick Wins
1.8%
+50% improvement
Full Optimization
2.5%
+108% improvement

Based on industry benchmarks for secondhand/resale e-commerce in emerging markets. Actual results depend on traffic quality and implementation.

Homepage Audit

📱 Mobile View (70% of traffic)
Homepage
1
2
✓
3

✓ What's Working

  • → WhatsApp button prominent
  • → Clear category navigation
  • → Sustainability messaging
  • → Clean, uncluttered design

✗ Issues Found

  • → No trust badges above fold
  • → No free shipping banner
  • → "Sell with us" before "Shop"
  • → Only 3 new arrivals shown
1
No Trust Banner in Header
Add a slim banner: "✓ COD Available · ✓ 100% Inspected · ✓ Free Shipping over PKR 5,000"
Expected impact: +15-25% visitor confidence
2
"Sell With Us" Messaging Distracts Buyers
The hero banner focuses on sellers, not buyers. Lead with "Shop Pre-loved Baby Essentials" instead.
Expected impact: +10% homepage-to-product click-through
3
Weak "Shop Now" CTA
Button blends with purple background. Needs high-contrast color (white or cyan) and stronger copy like "Browse All Items".
Expected impact: +20% CTA clicks

Homepage Recommendations

Add Announcement Bar with Trust Signals
Quick Win Low Effort

Add a sticky announcement bar above the header with key trust signals that matter to Pakistani shoppers:

  • "🚚 Free Delivery over PKR 5,000"
  • "💵 Cash on Delivery Available"
  • "✓ Every Item Inspected & Sanitized"
Expected Impact
+15-20% visitor trust, reduced bounce rate
Increase New Arrivals Display
Quick Win Low Effort

Currently showing only 3 products. Increase to 6-8 products, or add "View All New Arrivals" with product count badge ("42 new items this week").

Expected Impact
+25% engagement with product discovery

Product Page Audit

📱 Product Page - In Stock
Product Page
✓
1
2
✓

✓ What's Working

  • → Reviews present (5.0 ⭐)
  • → WhatsApp contact option
  • → "Buy it Now" button
  • → Size Guide available
  • → Multiple product images

✗ Issues Found

  • → No shipping/delivery info
  • → No trust badges
  • → No urgency (1 of 1 item!)
  • → "Sold Out" items in recommended
1
No Delivery Information
Shoppers need to know when they'll receive the item. Add "🚚 Estimated delivery: 3-5 business days" below the price.
Expected impact: +18% add-to-cart rate
2
Missing Scarcity Indicators
This is a secondhand marketplace — every item is unique! Add "Only 1 available" or "One-of-a-kind" badge prominently.
Expected impact: +37% urgency-driven purchases

Product Page Recommendations

Add "Only 1 Available" Badge
Critical Low Effort

Every secondhand item is unique. This is your biggest conversion lever. Add a prominent badge:

🔥 Only 1 Available — Don't Miss Out!

Place it near the Add to Cart button. This leverages loss aversion psychology.

Expected Impact
+30-40% conversion on product pages
Add Trust Badge Row Below CTA
High Low Effort

Add horizontal trust badges immediately below the Add to Cart button:

✓ COD Available ✓ Inspected & Sanitized ✓ Easy Returns
Expected Impact
+42% checkout completion rate
Filter "Sold Out" from Recommendations
High Medium Effort

The "Recently Viewed Products" section shows multiple sold-out items. This creates frustration and signals low inventory. Filter to show only in-stock items, or replace with "You May Also Like" with available products.

Expected Impact
Reduced bounce, better cross-sell performance

Cart & Checkout Audit

🛒 Cart Page
Cart Page
✓
1
2
💳 Checkout
Checkout
✓
3
1
No Upsells or Cross-sells
Cart page has no product recommendations. Add "Complete the Set" or "Mamas Also Bought" section.
Expected impact: +15-25% AOV increase
2
No Free Shipping Progress
If free shipping exists at PKR 5,000+, show a progress bar: "Add PKR 2,000 more for FREE shipping!"
Expected impact: +26% AOV from shipping threshold motivation
3
No Express Checkout
No Shop Pay, Apple Pay, or Google Pay. Single-click checkout increases mobile conversion significantly.
Expected impact: +30% mobile checkout completion

✓ What's Working Well

COD Available

Critical for Pakistan — 40-60% of orders use COD.

Single Page Checkout

Reduces friction vs. multi-step checkout.

WhatsApp Button

Persistent across all pages for easy support.

Special Instructions Field

Allows buyer notes — useful for secondhand items.

Top 5 Quick Wins

Implementable this week with minimal development effort.

1
Add Trust Banner to Header
Slim announcement bar: "✓ COD Available · ✓ Inspected & Sanitized · ✓ Free Shipping over PKR 5,000"
Impact: +15-20% trust | Effort: 30 mins
2
Add "Only 1 Available" Badge to Products
Every secondhand item is unique. Leverage scarcity with prominent badge near Add to Cart.
Impact: +30-40% CVR | Effort: 1-2 hours
3
Show Delivery Estimate on Product Pages
Add "🚚 Delivery: 3-5 business days to Karachi/Lahore/Islamabad" below price.
Impact: +18% ATC rate | Effort: 1 hour
4
Filter Sold Out from Recommendations
Remove sold-out items from "Recently Viewed" and recommendation sections.
Impact: Reduced frustration | Effort: 1 hour
5
Add Free Shipping Progress Bar to Cart
"Add PKR 2,000 more for FREE shipping!" with visual progress bar.
Impact: +26% AOV | Effort: 2 hours (app install)

Implementation Roadmap

Week 1-2 Critical Fixes
Action Category Impact Effort
Add trust banner to header Trust Very High Low
Add "Only 1 Available" scarcity badge Urgency Very High Low
Add delivery estimate to product pages Trust High Low
Filter sold-out from recommendations UX High Low
Week 3-4 High Impact
Action Category Impact Effort
Install free shipping progress bar app AOV High Low
Add cart upsell/cross-sell section AOV High Medium
Improve hero CTA contrast Homepage Medium Low
Increase New Arrivals display count Discovery Medium Low
Month 2+ Optimization
Action Category Impact Effort
Enable Shop Pay / Express Checkout Checkout High Medium
Add product videos for key items Product High High
Implement abandoned cart email/SMS Recovery High Medium
A/B test hero messaging Homepage Medium Medium

Recommended Shopify Apps

Issue App Cost
Free shipping bar Hextom Free Shipping Bar Free
Trust badges Trust Badges Bear / Vitals Free-$29/mo
Upsells ReConvert / Candy Rack $7.99+/mo
Abandoned cart Klaviyo / Omnisend Free-$20/mo
Reviews boost Judge.me Free